Much of the German press - or at least that part of it visible on the internet - is in uproar today about the TERRIBLE harm the vuvuzela is doing to the atmosphere of this year's World Cup. The top story at Der Spiegel right now is "Viel Lärm um Nichts" (i.e. "much noise about nothing"); there's an almost identical but even sharper-tongued polemic-masquerading-as-journalism heading the page of Berlin's Tagesspiegel; and of course Bild is not going to be outdone:
Distraction for the players, unfair advantage to the African teams [one word: earplugs], the death of the stadium atmosphere, horrible irritation for viewers around the world, oh oh oh end of the world as we know it should have been banned but everyone's too afraid of being called "racist" yet how absurd to claim it's their "culture" because only just imported from America grumble grr hissy.
And in all these articles none of them seem to suspect for a moment that it might just be them - or at least that they might possibly be a tad more sensitive to it than a lot of other nations. I've just gone through quite a number of British, French and even Australian news sites. Result: nothing. Not a single murmur of protest to be found. Not even among the usual suspects like the UK's Sun or Daily Mail.
It doesn't really surprise me because a couple of weeks ago I read - and translated - a rather more sympathetic German take on the African stadium sound:
- And did the fans in the stadium have their vuvuzela trumpets with them, which have become so famous since the Confederations Cup?
- Of course! Even at games with maybe just 20,000 spectators in a stadium for 50,000, it generated an unbelievable atmosphere, as if 100,000 fans were there. It was a constant droning and roaring in the stands, just brilliant. It might seem a bit more annoying on television, but in the stadium it's really amazing. The Bundesliga in Germany is a total contrast. Shortly before our departure I was able to go to a Hamburger SV match. If there's not so much happening on the pitch at a particular point in time, then the spectators are simply quiet. Only when the ball gets close to the penalty area does it get a bit louder. In Africa it's ninety minutes of non-stop noise.
Aha, alles klar. Über allen Gipfeln ist Ruh, in allen Wipfeln spürest du
kaum einen Hauch; die Vögelein schweigen im Walde... or at least until a squirrel kicks the acorn into the corner of the hollow trunk, presumably.
(To their credit, some of the German newspeople seem to have kept their cultural sensitivities in check, so far at least: I can't find any objections being raised at www.taz.de, www.sueddeutsche.de, or even at www.faz.de. Except in the reader comments sections, but let's just not go there...)
PS: The sound the vuvuzelas make on the tv broadcasts is EXACTLY the same as a bunch of blowflies flying around. People watching in outback Australia probably haven't even noticed it. Either that or they keep getting up to find out who left the screen door open.
No comments:
Post a Comment